All Dynamic Page (title) redirecting to same page

Guys, I know some of you will think I am dumb but I got to ask this. So I have a category (all) page right? It is the category “Anime Review”. I also have three item (title) pages - Dragon Ball Z, Naruto, Bleach. So when I click on the Dragon Ball Z link in the category page I go to the item review BUT when I click on the others, I still end up going to “Dragon Ball Z” review page. What am I doing wrong?