Identical repeaters displaying different amounts of buttons

I’m having an issue where one of my repeaters is displaying the correct amount of buttons (57) but the other is only able to display 30. They are both set to display up to 60 items

I’m not sure where the issue is coming from because I duplicated the working repeater and only changed the name, the database its linked to, and the option its linked to.

Both databases are exactly the same aside from a different name.

I’d like to know what is causing one of my repeaters to display differently than the other

Attached are images to help show what I’m talking about.