Website Permission Issue - I can get into Website without password

Question:
I added member only permission to each page of my wix website. I restricted it to only members I approve. I published the website and tested it out. When I incorrectly enter the password. I get a message stating “You Don’t Have Permission to Access this Page”. Then I have two options “Back To Site” or “Switch Accounts”. When I click back to site, it takes me directly into the site without having to login. Am I missing a permission option? Does anyone know how to resolve this issue?

Product:
Wix Editor

What are you trying to achieve:
I’m trying to only have members that I want to have access to the entire site have access. I’ve set Permissions to Members only.

What have you already tried:
I’ve added permissions, but don’t know how to get to the page that has the “back to site” button to remove it.

Additional information:
I would like for the members to only view the site, not be site collaborators